October 29th, 2008

Nothing about the stock market is too predictable…what you expect usually does not happen.

Some will disagree. For them, the direction of the market is clear. At least clear when claiming prescience. They’ll never admit when wrong; they will boldy exclaim and humiliate when right.

Stock trading intra-day has relevance, but what seems to matter most is what the market indexes say at 4PM (or after the final trades settle around 4:10 or later).

Here are three observations:
• Volatility prevails
• The better hedge funds seem to be standing on the sideline
• Nobody is really certain about what happens next; Those who are certain see “gloom and doom”
• Many wait for the next economic “shoe-to-drop”

Finally, whatever happened to dollar-cost-averaging?

Never have I observed such a dispirit mass of views, political dysfunction, and public confusion. Dispirit views can be expected whenever discussion ocurrs, but political dysfunction is not what a democracy needs. Public confusion erupts because there is a lack of government leadership and public knowledge. When a crisis arrives, no one can decide on what works, and no one leads. All parties appear to play the zero-sum game: give me all I want and I’ll give you nothing of what you want, or I’ll give up something as long as you know there’s hell-to-pay.

Most people get their stock market updates from the evening news. The excitement on the way up with the gloom and doom during a market correction. Very few get much of an education. Duncan Niederauer, CEO of the New York Stock Exchange recognized this by statiing that many voters fail to understand the inextricable link between “Main Street and Wall Street”.

American voters think this is a “bailout of Wall Street”. What we face is a “credit-crisis”. Small businesses faces payroll challenges, the U.S. auto industry has no wheels, and the housing industry has no foundation. As Secretary Paulson said, “…this is much too important to let this fail,” Paulson said.

House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer said, “Why should taxpayers loan out their own money to solve a crisis brought on by someone else’s greed?” He answered his own question by saying, “…in our economy, none of us is an island. A meltdown would begin…on a few square miles of Manhattan, but before it was over…no city or town in America would be untouched.”

Mutual fund, 401(k), endowment fund, and pension investors can blame Wall Street “fat cats”, but we all chased the mice. We all gloated and took pride in the numbers on our statements. “No city or town in America” ran from the market upside, but everyone wants to blame someone on the downside.

The greater the excess or hubris, the greater the humiliation. The greater the cynicism, the greater the deliberative dysfunction when seeking a resolution. The greater the market avarice on both sides of a trade (long by owning stock and selling or shorting a stock)the worse the results for everyday, steady-hearted investors.

We can only hope that time and sensibility return our sanity. We can only hope that the stock market becomes a thermometer of economic growth, research and development, entrepreneural innovation, and a cooperative effort to keep this planet revolving for our kids.